A man dies of a stroke in front of a mirror but Sam and Dean believe something, or someone else (Bloody Mary), may be behind his death. Dean tries to help Sam open up about his girlfriend's death, particularly after Sam lets it slip that there's some... (more) information that he hasn't told Dean.

Adrianne Palicki, Chelan Simmons, Duncan Minett, Genevieve Buechner, James Ashcroft, Jessica King, Jovanna Burke (née Huguet), Kristie Marsden, Marnette Patterson, Michael Teigen, Victoria Tennant, William Taylor