Det. Stillman asks Lilly to re-open a case he couldn't solve, wherein an 8-year-old boy, Tim Barnes, was murdered in 1980. The prime suspects included a catholic priest, three glue-sniffing teenagers, one elusive suspect, and the boy's own parents.

Anne Thomas, Asa Bernstine, Candace Edwards, Chelsea Field, Eden Rountree, Emily Yancy, Jason Alan Smith, Jhaton Robinson, John Lawlor, Jordan Wooden, Marc McClure, Michael McGrady, Nicholas Mitchell, Ray Campbell, Sean Carrigan, Terry Wilkerson, Trent J. Cameron