Annie Miller disappears on her way to school. The group looks into her disappearance, with their suspects ranging from the local mayor, to Annie's godfather, all the way to a young man working for the father of her best friend. Twenty-four hours afte... (more)r Annie's disappearance, her best friend Siobhan Arintero also vanishes, leaving only a collection of videos to help find the two girls.

Alia Shawkat, Carlos Alvarado, Colette Kilroy, Daniel Zacapa, Judith Hoag, Landry Allbright, Louise Davis, Michaela Watkins, Robert Curtis Brown, Tom Gallop, Tony Halstead, Vito D'Ambrosio